Startups

Pitch Deck Teardown: Careerist’s $8M Series A deck

Comment

Image Credits: Careerist (opens in a new window)

Careerist claims it closed an $8 million round of funding with a tight 12-slide deck and gave us a lot to learn from in the process. Not all in good ways, but I’m getting slightly ahead of myself.


We’re looking for more unique pitch decks to tear down, so if you want to submit your own, here’s how you can do that


Slides in this deck

The team submitted this slide deck with the note that it was submitted exactly as it pitched it to the investors.

  1. Cover slide
  2. Mission slide
  3. Problem slide
  4. Solution slide
  5. Traction slide part 1
  6. Traction slide part 2
  7. Business model slide
  8. Go to market/customer funnel slide
  9. Client rating and net promoter score slide
  10.   Market slide
  11.   Team slide
  12.   Thank you slide

Three things to love

This deck sets off a number of alarm bells for me — I’ll get to why in just a moment — and I imagine the founding team fought an uphill battle pitching this to investors. Having said that, the company did go through Y Combinator and claims it was successful in raising an $8 million round from Cathexis, Xploration, Cold Start Ventures, Grant Park Ventures and others. Let’s dig in and look to see if we can find some clues as to why the company caught the eye of these investors.

If you have traction, nothing else matters

[Slide 5] Traction is king. Image Credits: Careerist

Traction truly resolves any issues a company may possibly have. Building a company that is growing from half a million dollars to $12 million of revenue in four years is pretty impressive, especially given that up to this point, according to its own press release, the company had raised just $1.2 million of capital. Turning $1.2 million of investment into $12 million of revenue, it turns out, is enough to catch the attention of investors.

Extraordinary customer acquisition

In order to drive that much revenue, you’ve got to find your customers somewhere, and it seems like Careerist cracked that nut:

[Slide 8] That’s some serious growth hacking there. Image Credits: Careerist

On its slides, the company claims that it gets 35% of its traffic organically and another 25% from referrals. Those are two extremely powerful, low-cost acquisition channels that can drive extraordinary, high-value customers. But that’s a double-edged sword. Referrals generally do scale well alongside other channels: If you get a 0.2 referral on average per customer, and you acquire 10 customers, you get two “free” customers due to referrals. The challenge is with the organic traffic, which is much harder to scale on demand. In other words, once you close an $8 million round of funding, how are you going to accelerate your sales dramatically?

It doesn’t specify whether the other channels (Google, webinars and Facebook) are paid acquisition channels. If they are, I’d expect to see the cost of acquisition (CAC) here, and an analysis on whether these customers also end up referring additional customers. But overall, there’s a lot to love on this slide: Finding 1,600 customers who are paying you $12,000+ each (see slide 7 in the slide deck, below) is objectively impressive.

The cool thing is, you can sense-check those numbers: The company claims that it has 1,600 customers and has done cumulative $19 million of revenue. That works out to around $12,000 per customer, proving that the numbers are internally consistent.

That’s a hell of a market size

[Slide 10] E-learning is huge, finding jobs is popular and hiring the right staff is crucial. That all adds up. Image Credits: Careerist

Careerist finds itself in a curious space here, with a huge opportunity. In fact, if the company wasn’t seeing extraordinary traction and lifetime value (LTV), these numbers would be hard to believe. But with the traction in place, these numbers seem more or less plausible. Besides, in truly enormous markets (hiring, training, etc.) market sizing is essentially just a checkbox.

One example of that would be toothpaste: There’s no doubt that there’s a huge market for it, and no investor will argue with you about that. The questions then become “What can you do to gain a foothold in those markets?” and “What are your marketing and customer acquisition channels?” Careerist only partially answers those questions, and that worries me a little.

The above are some of the positives in the Careerist pitch deck, but unfortunately, there are also a few Texas-sized red flags that make me wonder how the company was successful in raising money at all. I suspect the answer, as I alluded to above, is because of its traction. In the rest of this teardown, I’ll take a look at three things Careerist could have improved or done differently, along with its full pitch deck.

Three things that could be improved

There are quite a few things missing or problematic in this deck, and unfortunately it starts right when you open the first slide.

That’s a major red flag

On the cover of its slide deck, it shows a quote from TechCrunch. Sure, it misspells the name of the publication (it’s TechCrunch, not Techcrunch), but that’s forgivable.

[Slide 1] Oh dear. Image Credits: Careerist

Whenever I am evaluating a pitch deck, I verify as many of the claims I can on a deck.

Let me share an example. Careerist claims that 50 million people in the U.S. change jobs every year. That sounds way too high, so I did some cursory Googling to check it out. I found that “The average person will change careers 10 to 15 times during their working years.” If the average person works from age 18 to 68, that means they work for 50 years. Divide by 15 and you get an average tenure of about three years. “In 2022, it was estimated that over 158 million Americans were in some form of employment,” with every person changing jobs every three years or so.

That means that the numbers add up, more or less: The 50 million people changing jobs number seems high, but it’s probably roughly correct.

So, when I saw a slide deck that quotes TechCrunch on the cover, you’d better believe that I did a quick search to find anything we wrote about the company. It turns out that the only time TechCrunch has written about Careerist is in the summary of all the Y Combinator companies in August 2021. That isn’t really market validation; we wrote about 377 startups in that cohort, and we only wrote a very short summary of each of them. Most importantly; what the company says we wrote, we didn’t actually write:

Screenshot from our “Here are all the companies from Y Combinator’s Summer 2021 Demo Day, Part 1” article. Image Credits: Haje Jan Kamps/TechCrunch

The company added the “[and fintech]” to our quote. The use of square brackets in quotes is sometimes used editorially to clarify a quote. For example, if a founder is talking about a fundraise, but refers to the fundraise as “it” in a quote, we might replace it with a phrase that makes it more clear. That would update the quote from, “Oh, we had a hard time with it,” to “Oh, we had a hard time with [the fundraise].” It’s worth noting that in the quote Careerist uses on the cover of this slide deck, there’s no reference to fintech in our article anywhere. Journalistically that is super problematic. At serious publications, that’s known as fabricating quotes, and it could get you fired on the spot.

Of course, a pitch deck is not journalism, but as an investor, that put me on super high alert: If a company is willing to bend the truth on a cover slide, what other truths will it distort? It made me go back and try to fact check whether the fundraising round even took place. I couldn’t find any publication that covered the $8 million round. The only reference I could find to it is on Business Insider, but that article is also about the pitch deck, not about the fundraise.

I reached out to all the investors the company claimed invested in the round, but I wasn’t able to confirm before the time of publication that it was an $8 million round nor that the firm was a part of the round. Only one of the investors lists Careerists on its portfolio page. As a media-savvy investor, that is just red flag after red flag after red flag. That doesn’t mean I wouldn’t invest in the company per se, but it would make me do extra-thorough due diligence in the deal.

The worst part is that the TechCrunch quote isn’t even helpful. It’s just a quick summarization of what the company is, not a review or analysis; it merely appeared on a list.

How are you going to grow?

Careerist’s pitch deck is almost completely devoid of any information about what the company is going to do next. That’s highly unusual (and a little suspicious). Raising a funding round typically means that you’re building something new, maybe to expand your sales or to help build the company in other ways. That could take the shape of an ask slide, an operating plan, a product roadmap or a go-to-market plan.

None of these exists in Careerist’s deck.

Judging from the deck alone, it looks like the company has no plan for what it wants to do with the money, and without a clear vision for what the funds would accomplish. Leaving out this crucially important set of info is doing Careerist a disservice: Investors are going to want to see some sort of plan, and this is the place to share that.

Slide 8 (as discussed above) does this a little bit by outlining how the company is acquiring customers — and with a customer value north of $12,000, it can certainly afford to spend some money here. However, the company fails to explain in any amount of detail what its plan is to reach its next group of customers. In fact, Careerist brags about how it is acquiring customers through channels that don’t scale easily, which does the opposite of build confidence.

What are these numbers‽

[Slide 9] This shows … what? Image Credits: Careerist

This slide is extraordinarily confusing, because it includes a number of different numbers. The Career Karma and Switchup reviews track; the number of reviews has gone up for both; and the rating remains high. However, the company claims to have 78 reviews with a 4.5 rating on TrustPilot. As I’m writing this, it has 40 reviews with a 4.0 rating. I have questions. The other thing that confuses me is the comparison with Udemy and Coursera; these are very different industries. That either means that I have misunderstood Careerist’s business and business model, or the company’s making an apples-to-oranges comparison. Not sure which, but it’s generally not advisable to confuse your investors.

I’m also confused about the NPS scores. The net promoter score is usually a response to a single question: “Would you be willing to recommend a business or product to a friend, colleague or acquaintance.” The answer is on a 1 to 10 scale. From there, you take the answer and calculate the NPS based on a formula. Most companies have one NPS for the whole company and maybe one NPS per product. In other words, the left-most question (“How likely are you to recommend Careerist”) is how I would expect to see an NPS question. The rest of the questions don’t make sense and are not NPS scores: “How likely are you to recommend your homework and assignments to your colleagues” is a nonsensical question. It’s possible that the company asked its customers how happy they are with the lessons, homework, internship and mentors, but those numbers don’t flow to NPS scores.

In a deck that is lacking many real, meaningful numbers, my Spidey-sense starts a-tingling when the numbers that are there are partial or seem to be nonstandard.

I know I already praised the company’s traction chart (slide 5), but now that I’m sitting with the numbers and thinking about them, I’m not sure about that number, either. Revenue in isolation is impressive but not helpful to ascertain whether a company is viable. I’d also want to see customer lifetime value over time, customer acquisition cost, cost of goods sold, etc.

The company does say it has $2 million in revenue and $500,000 in monthly EBITDA. For most stock-listed companies, if your EBITDA is above 15%, you have an impressive business (here, we are looking at 25%, so that’s good). But for a company that is trying to look like a tech company, I’m left to wonder what all those costs are and whether there’s an opportunity for increasing the margins. Again, those are metrics that I would expect founders to track and be able to report on, especially at the Series A stage, but once again, that’s missing here.

Given that I’m already suspicious about the deck overall, why the company seems to be hiding so many of the important numbers rings all my alarm bells at once.

A final note

This pitch deck teardown is pretty salty, and I’ve repeated several times that I’m on high alert and worried about the veracity of the data in the deck. I hasten to add that I have no additional context here beyond the deck itself. That’s unusual for an investor, and realistically, if I received this pitch, I would take a meeting with the company based on the traction and revenue graph alone. From there, perhaps the company has a tight voiceover that explains all the misgivings and suspicions that arise.

Or maybe the company has an incredible live financial dashboard that it pulls up as part of a pitch. And maybe it has a detailed plan for how much it is raising, what it will accomplish with those funds and how it will raise its Series B in 18 to 24 months.

On its own, this deck is lacking a lot of important information, which makes it not an ideal deck (pitch decks should be able to stand on their own, and if not, consider providing a send-home deck). The main caveat is that it’s a very different experience being walked through a deck rather than just picking it apart out of context.

Having said that, check out Orange Chargers’ deck to see an example of a deck that gets all of the above very right.

The full pitch deck


If you want your own pitch deck teardown featured on TC+, here’s more information. Also, check out all our Pitch Deck Teardowns and other pitching advice, all collected in one handy place for you!

More TechCrunch

TechCrunch Disrupt, our flagship startup event held annually in San Francisco, is back on October 28-30 — and you can expect a bustling crowd of thousands of startup enthusiasts. Exciting…

Startup Blueprint: TC Disrupt 2024 Builders Stage agenda sneak peek!

Mike Krieger, one of the co-founders of Instagram and, more recently, the co-founder of personalized news app Artifact (which TechCrunch corporate parent Yahoo recently acquired), is joining Anthropic as the…

Anthropic hires Instagram co-founder as head of product

Seven orgs so far have signed on to standardize the way data is collected and shared.

Venture orgs form alliance to standardize data collection

As cloud adoption continues to surge towards the $1 trillion mark in annual spend, we’re seeing a wave of enterprise startups gaining traction with customers and investors for tools to…

Alkira connects with $100M for a solution that connects your clouds

Charging has long been the Achilles’ heel of electric vehicles. One startup thinks it has a better way for apartment dwelling EV drivers to charge overnight.

Orange Charger thinks a $750 outlet will solve EV charging for apartment dwellers

So did investors laugh them out of the room when they explained how they wanted to replace Quickbooks? Kind of.

Embedded accounting startup Layer secures $2.3M toward goal of replacing Quickbooks

While an increasing number of companies are investing in AI, many are struggling to get AI-powered projects into production — much less delivering meaningful ROI. The challenges are many. But…

Weka raises $140M as the AI boom bolsters data platforms

PayHOA, a previously bootstrapped Kentucky-based startup that offers software for self-managed homeowner associations (HOAs), is an example of how real-world problems can translate into opportunity. It just raised a $27.5…

Meet PayHOA, a profitable and once-bootstrapped SaaS startup that just landed a $27.5M Series A

Restaurant365, which offers a restaurant management suite, has raised a hot $175M from ICONIQ Growth, KKR and L Catterton.

Restaurant365 orders in $175M at $1B+ valuation to supersize its food service software stack 

Venture firm Shilling has launched a €50M fund to support growth-stage startups in its own portfolio and to invest in startups everywhere else. 

Portuguese VC firm Shilling launches €50M opportunity fund to back growth-stage startups

Chang She, previously the VP of engineering at Tubi and a Cloudera veteran, has years of experience building data tooling and infrastructure. But when She began working in the AI…

LanceDB, which counts Midjourney as a customer, is building databases for multimodal AI

Trawa simplifies energy purchasing and management for SMEs by leveraging an AI-powered platform and downstream data from customers. 

Berlin-based trawa raises €10M to use AI to make buying renewable energy easier for SMEs

Lydia is splitting itself into two apps — Lydia for P2P payments and Sumeria for those looking for a mobile-first bank account.

Lydia, the French payments app with 8 million users, launches mobile banking app Sumeria

Cargo ships docking at a commercial port incur costs called “disbursements” and “port call expenses.” This might be port dues, towage, and pilotage fees. It’s a complex patchwork and all…

Shipping logistics startup Harbor Lab raises $16M Series A led by Atomico

AWS has confirmed its European “sovereign cloud” will go live by the end of 2025, enabling greater data residency for the region.

AWS confirms will launch European ‘sovereign cloud’ in Germany by 2025, plans €7.8B investment over 15 years

Go Digit, an Indian insurance startup, has raised $141 million from investors including Goldman Sachs, ADIA, and Morgan Stanley as part of its IPO.

Indian insurance startup Go Digit raises $141M from anchor investors ahead of IPO

Peakbridge intends to invest in between 16 and 20 companies, investing around $10 million in each company. It has made eight investments so far.

Food VC Peakbridge has new $187M fund to transform future of food, like lab-made cocoa

For over six decades, the nonprofit has been active in the financial services sector.

Accion’s new $152.5M fund will back financial institutions serving small businesses globally

Meta’s newest social network, Threads, is starting its own fact-checking program after piggybacking on Instagram and Facebook’s network for a few months.

Threads finally starts its own fact-checking program

Looking Glass makes trippy-looking mixed-reality screens that make things look 3D without the need of special glasses. Today, it launches a pair of new displays, including a 16-inch mode that…

Looking Glass launches new 3D displays

Replacing Sutskever is Jakub Pachocki, OpenAI’s director of research.

Ilya Sutskever, OpenAI co-founder and longtime chief scientist, departs

Intuitive Machines made history when it became the first private company to land a spacecraft on the moon, so it makes sense to adapt that tech for Mars.

Intuitive Machines wants to help NASA return samples from Mars

As Google revamps itself for the AI era, offering AI overviews within its search results, the company is introducing a new way to filter for just text-based links. With the…

Google adds ‘Web’ search filter for showing old-school text links as AI rolls out

Blue Origin’s New Shepard rocket will take a crew to suborbital space for the first time in nearly two years later this month, the company announced on Tuesday.  The NS-25…

Blue Origin to resume crewed New Shepard launches on May 19

This will enable developers to use the on-device model to power their own AI features.

Google is building its Gemini Nano AI model into Chrome on the desktop

It ran 110 minutes, but Google managed to reference AI a whopping 121 times during Google I/O 2024 (by its own count). CEO Sundar Pichai referenced the figure to wrap…

Google mentioned ‘AI’ 120+ times during its I/O keynote

Firebase Genkit is an open source framework that enables developers to quickly build AI into new and existing applications.

Google launches Firebase Genkit, a new open source framework for building AI-powered apps

In the coming months, Google says it will open up the Gemini Nano model to more developers.

Patreon and Grammarly are already experimenting with Gemini Nano, says Google

As part of the update, Reddit also launched a dedicated AMA tab within the web post composer.

Reddit introduces new tools for ‘Ask Me Anything,’ its Q&A feature

Here are quick hits of the biggest news from the keynote as they are announced.

Google I/O 2024: Here’s everything Google just announced