Google dials up focus on portability ahead of rule changes

Comment

The Google Inc. company logo sits on revolving doors
Image Credits: Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg / Getty Images

Google has signalled it’s dialling up efforts around portability, announcing a plan yesterday to spend $3 million and “hundreds of hours” of its engineers’ time over the next five years to build on existing (sometimes very long-standing) initiatives in this area, such as the 2018 open source Data Transfer Project (DTP) to which Google is a contributor.

The move comes at a time when lawmakers in multiple jurisdictions are paying increased attention to barriers that prevent service switching and interoperability — and considering how best to remove such friction from digital markets to foster competition, whether through new digital legislation, specific competition reforms and enforcement, or a blend of all three.

In its blog post announcing extra time and money for portability — to “help expand open source libraries that facilitate more types of data transfer and allow more companies and organizations to participate in DTP” — Google also sets out a series of its own policy priorities in this area, likely seeking to get out ahead of legislation and influence the shape of rules and regimes coming down the pipe.

In the European Union, for example, lawmakers are busy hammering out the fine details of the Digital Markets Act (DMA): An ex ante competition regime that will apply to the most powerful intermediating Internet platforms (aka “gatekeepers”) — which is almost certain to apply to Google and will bring in a long list of operational requirements that includes interoperability stipulations, among plenty of other behavioral mandates.

Europe proposes rules for fair access to connected device data

Beyond the EU, other countries and regions are also eyeing behavioral remedies and/or already taking antitrust enforcement already aimed at unblocking tipped digital markets by forcing tech giants to be more open than they have been — from Australia to South Korea to the U.K., to name a few.

While, over in the U.S. in recent years, the FTC has also been exploring portability through a consumer plus competition lens. (And Google’s business is also facing multiple antitrust charges on home soil.)

In its blog post, Google pledges to continue improving existing portability tools, like Google Takeout — “including adding new ways to move your files to different services with DTP technology” — noting that in average it sees 8.2 million exports per month with Google Takeout (with more than 400 billion files exported in 2021, which it says has doubled since 2019).

It also says it will “continue to support organizations and researchers working on portability and interoperability, and collaborate with them to develop industry-wide standards and guidance on this important issue”, as it puts it.

Google couches its own priorities for portability in terms of three “key principles” — claiming it will focus on consumer need by supporting “standards for the most common data types”, with the goal of accelerating portability for popular services like photos, playlists and contacts.

Google of course stands to gain if it’s easier for Spotify users, say, to port their playlists to Google Play Music or Instagram users to move all their media to Google Photos, even as portability may cut the other way and facilitate its own users to switch.

Given that, it’s no surprise that a second “key principle” Google is lobbying for here is exactly for portability to be reciprocal: “Platforms that allow people to import their data should also allow them to export it,” it writes, arguing that this “encourages people to try new services without the risk that they will lose their data”.

It has reasons to be concerned that this may not in fact always be the case. For example, the EU’s latest data reuse proposal — the Data Act — aims to foster competition in the IoT space by encouraging greater sharing of connected device data. However the draft legislation includes a specific stipulation that platforms which are classed as gatekeepers under the DMA won’t be able to make use of the legislation to receive third party companies’ data exactly to avoid the risk of them further entrenching their market power. So Google is likely to be shut out of those future IoT data flows.

Mountain View’s third claimed “key principle” is couched as a focus on “privacy and security”, with the tech giant arguing that portability regulations “must include safeguards against unauthorized access, diversion of data, and other types of fraud” — and specifically suggesting this should include “account authorization, encryption and delayed delivery”.

This too is familiar territory for adtech giants seeking to flip concern over their vast market power into a new strategy to maintain moats around their revenues by pushing to bake favorable limitations into incoming regulations.

Facebook, for example, has frequently warned that portability is “hard” to get right and could risk user privacy — including by suggesting the Cambridge Analytica scandal no less (!) was an example of too much openness being bad for people’s privacy and security.

Google looks similarly keen here to influence the scope of portability legislation in a way that could allow it to reintroduce enough selective friction — under the guise of “privacy and security” — to enable it to leverage its vast resources to streamline compliance with added stipulations attached to portability rules in a way that enables it to retain a competitive edge vs less well resourced rivals who can’t dedicate so much resource on hoop-jumping. Or that looks to be the aim.

Hence its blog post talks of supporting “responsible” data portability; and says it’s not “waiting for legal mandates”. Of course Google would prefer to build its own version of the data-driven future that’s not so very different to the current self-regulatory regime than having lawmakers set the parameters of data portability for it.

Just like Facebook, Google is quick to invoke a claim of privacy as a tactic to fend off regulations that could enforce true competition via data access — even as it footdrags over providing Internet users with privacy from it own data mining and ad targeting empire.

Lawmakers seem pretty wise to such disingenuous tactics by big tech — but as EU privacy campaigners could tell you it takes a whole village and years of hard graft to try to enforce regulations against tech giants, so Google and other gatekeeping giants may be banking on a little favorable regulatory friction going a long way.

Understanding Europe’s big push to rewrite the digital rulebook

More TechCrunch

Welcome to TechCrunch Fintech! This week, we’re looking at LoanSnap’s woes, Nubank’s and Monzo’s positive milestones, a plethora of fintech fundraises and more! To get a roundup of TechCrunch’s biggest…

A look at LoanSnap’s troubles and which neobanks are having a moment

Databricks, the analytics and AI giant, has acquired data management company Tabular for an undisclosed sum. (CNBC reports that Databricks payed over $1 billion.) According to Tabular co-founder Ryan Blue,…

Databricks acquires Tabular to build a common data lakehouse standard

ChatGPT, OpenAI’s text-generating AI chatbot, has taken the world by storm. What started as a tool to hyper-charge productivity through writing essays and code with short text prompts has evolved…

ChatGPT: Everything you need to know about the AI-powered chatbot

The next few weeks could be pivotal for Worldcoin, the controversial eyeball-scanning crypto venture co-founded by OpenAI’s Sam Altman, whose operations remain almost entirely shuttered in the European Union following…

Worldcoin faces pivotal EU privacy decision within weeks

It’s unusual for three major AI providers to all be down at the same time, which could signal a broader infrastructure issues or internet-scale problem.

AI apocalypse? ChatGPT, Claude and Perplexity all went down at the same time

OpenAI’s chatbot ChatGPT has been down for several users across the globe for the last few hours.

OpenAI fixes the issue that caused ChatGPT outage for several hours

True Fit, the AI-powered size-and-fit personalization tool, has offered its size recommendation solution to thousands of retailers for nearly 20 years. Now, the company is venturing into the generative AI…

True Fit leverages generative AI to help online shoppers find clothes that fit

Audio streaming service TuneIn is teaming up with Discord to bring free live radio to the platform. This is TuneIn’s first collaboration with a social platform and one that is…

Discord and TuneIn partner to bring live radio to the social platform

The early victors in the AI gold rush are selling the picks and shovels needed to develop and apply artificial intelligence. Just take a look at data-labeling startup Scale AI…

Scale AI founder Alexandr Wang is coming to Disrupt 2024

Try to imagine the number of parts that go into making a rocket engine. Now imagine requesting and comparing quotes for each of those parts, getting approvals to purchase the…

Engineer brothers found Forge to modernize hardware procurement

Raspberry Pi has released a $70 AI extension kit with a neural network inference accelerator that can be used for local inferencing, for the Raspberry Pi 5.

Raspberry Pi partners with Hailo for its AI extension kit

When Stacklet’s founders, Travis Stanfield and Kapil Thangavelu, came out of Capital One in 2020 to launch their startup, most companies weren’t all that concerned with constraining cloud costs. But…

Stacklet sees demand grow as companies take cloud cost control more seriously

Fivetran’s Managed Data Lake Service aims to remove the repetitive work of managing data lakes.

Fivetran launches a managed data lake service

Lance Riedel and Nigel Daley both spent decades in search discovery, but it was while working at Pinterest that they began trying to understand how to use search engines to…

How a couple of former Pinterest search experts caught Biz Stone’s attention

GetWhy helps businesses carry out market studies and extract insights from video-based interviews using AI.

GetWhy, a market research AI platform that extracts insights from video interviews, raises $34.5M

AI-powered virtual physical therapy platform Sword Health has seen its valuation soar 50% to $3 billion.

Sword Health raises $130 million and its valuation soars to $3 billion

Jeffrey Katzenberg and Sujay Jaswa, along with three general partners, manage $1.5 billion in assets today through their Build, Venture and Seed strategies.

WndrCo officially gets into venture capital with fresh $460M across two funds

The startup targets the middle ground between platforms that offer rigid templates, and those that facilitate a full-control approach.

Storyblok raises $80M to add more AI to its ‘headless’ CMS aimed at non-technical people

The startup has been pursuing a ground-up redesign of a well-understood technology.

‘Star Wars’ lasers and waterfalls of molten salt: How Xcimer plans to make fusion power happen

Sékr, a startup that offers a mobile app for outdoor enthusiasts and campers, is launching a new AI tool for planning road trips. The new tool, called Copilot, is available…

Travel app Sékr can plan your next road trip with its new AI tool

Microsoft’s education-focused flavor of its cloud productivity suite, Microsoft 365 Education, is facing investigation in the European Union. Privacy rights non-profit noyb has just lodged two complaints with Austria’s data…

Microsoft hit with EU privacy complaints over schools’ use of 365 Education suite

Since the shock of Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine, solar energy has been having a moment in Europe. Electricity prices have been going up while the investment required to get…

Samara is accelerating the energy transition in Spain one solar panel at a time

Featured Article

DEI backlash: Stay up-to-date on the latest legal and corporate challenges

It’s clear that this year will be a turning point for DEI.

18 hours ago
DEI backlash: Stay up-to-date on the latest legal and corporate challenges

The keynote will be focused on Apple’s software offerings and the developers that power them, including the latest versions of iOS, iPadOS, macOS, tvOS, visionOS and watchOS.

Watch Apple kick off WWDC 2024 right here

Hello and welcome back to TechCrunch Space. Unfortunately, Boeing’s Starliner launch was delayed yet again, this time due to issues with one of the three redundant computers used by United…

TechCrunch Space: China’s victory

The court ruling said that Fearless Fund’s Strivers Grant likely violates the Civil Rights Act of 1866, which bans the use of race in contracts.

An appeals court rules that VC Fearless Fund cannot issue grants to Black women, but the fight continues

Instagram Threads is rolling out the ability for users to signal which sort of posts they wanted to see more or less of by swiping.

You can now customize your For You feed on Threads using swipes

The Japanese billionaire who commissioned SpaceX for a private mission around the moon on a Starship rocket has abruptly canceled the project, citing ongoing uncertainties around when the launch vehicle…

Japanese billionaire pulls plug on private ‘dearMoon’ lunar Starship mission

Malicious actors are abusing generative AI music tools to create homophobic, racist, and propagandic songs — and publishing guides instructing others how to do so. According to ActiveFence, a service…

People are using AI music generators to create hateful songs

As WWDC 2024 nears, all sorts of rumors and leaks have emerged about what iOS 18 and its AI-powered apps and features have in store.

What to expect from Apple’s AI-powered iOS 18 at WWDC