The truth about due diligence

Comment

There’s an expression in venture capital. It’s called the “Oh, shit” board meeting. “That’s when you learn all sorts of things that you wish you’d known after writing a company that first check,” says general partner David Hornik of August Capital.

It’s easy to imagine that they’ve been happening regularly across the startup industry. The pace of funding in recent years has been feverish, giving investors less time than ever to assess the startups they’re funding. That once-celebrated companies like the blood testing outfit Theranos, and the wireless charging company uBeam, are seemingly fighting for their lives raises plenty of questions, too.

A recent Vanity Fair piece blamed Silicon Valley media (and TechCrunch in particular) for the rise of certain companies. Meanwhile, a story published earlier this week in Fast Company suggested a culture of spin is at the root of the problem. As one founder told the outlet, “Being honest in Silicon Valley is like being the one member of an Olympic team that isn’t on steroids.”

Of course, none of us would likely have heard of Theranos or uBeam if not for investors, who’ve given the companies $686 million and $25 million, respectively. Were these backers overly optimistic? Did they get duped? Were they even paying attention? It’s easy to wag our fingers as we wait to see how these narratives unfold, but here’s the truth: due diligence only goes so far. While some may think it a scientific process that insulates venture firms from bad investments, due diligence is a surprisingly imperfect process with plenty of limitations.

“If you’re looking for a black or white answer in doing diligence, it’ll be a fail,” says Matt Murphy, a former Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers partner who joined Menlo Ventures a year ago as a managing director. “You’re usually dealing with shades of gray.”

The truth will set you free

As you might imagine, due diligence means different things, depending on the sector in which a startup is operating and the stage of its development. At the outset, say VCs, it usually involves some combination of gut instinct, research into the market opportunity (when there’s a market to research), and, done properly, lots of calls about the founder who’s pitching them.

“The challenge you have when it’s early days is an entrepreneur with nothing to sell but vision,” says Bob Ackerman, the founder and managing director of Allegis Capital.

Typically, VCs are handed references, and those are easy enough. “You’re usually introduced to a set of people who’ve worked with the entrepreneur, and you have that set of calls and they go well, because the entrepreneur has steered you to those people,” says Hornik.

If a VC is really doing his or her homework, that person will then find former colleagues of the founder who aren’t on their list of referrals.

Even then, some reading between the lines is required. “The natural inclination of people is say perfectly nice things, even when someone hasn’t done a good job,” says Hornik. “When someone tells me that someone ‘did a great job,’ and that they were a ‘good leader,’ that’s a bad reference. A good reference is, ‘This person is amazing. I would work with her again in a heartbeat.’ That’s what you want.”

The same is true of customer calls later in a startup’s trajectory. Naturally, VCs are given the names of customers who are predisposed to like the company. But “you have to find off references,’” says Murphy of Menlo Ventures. “If the potential buyer is a chief security officer, then you talk with some CSOs who the company hasn’t spoken with and you explain the product and the pain point and you ask if they would take a meeting or, sometimes, whether there’s another competitor that they are working with.”

Due diligence looks different depending on the opportunity, too. Jonathan Abrams, the founder of social news aggregator Nuzzel, is a limited partner in the funds of Data Collective, a San Francisco-based venture firm that prides itself on making wide-ranging bets, from satellites to antiviral therapeutics. Abrams notes that, as with many firms, Data Collective has advisors who are PhDs in numerous specialties to help them with due diligence around products the partners might not understand as well.

“If you’re investing in the next Snapchat or Slack, many VCs might feel confident investing on their own,” says Abrams. “When you’re investing in something that’s harder to understand, that’s less likely to happen.”

Just the facts, ma’am

That’s not to say that VCs couldn’t be doing a better job. For example, it’s easy for investors to lose touch with what’s happening, especially when they’re funding more mature startups, sit on a large number of boards, and/or don’t feel the need to keep close tabs on things. (One founder who asked not to be named calls one of his follow-on investors a “good-time Charlie,” implying the firm doesn’t do a whole lot for the company.)

Even board members who are engaged can be deceived in tough times. “It’s no problem for entrepreneurs to mislead you when you’re on the board,” says Hornik. “Where [you] find out that a CFO has been lying or someone has stealing, you sort of say, ‘What could I have done?’ But the reality is that as a board member, you aren’t auditing the company. The best thing you can do is have a close relationship with people throughout the company, so you can hear what’s going on from a range of sources. If you don’t, it increases the likelihood that you can be vaguely misled.”

VCs can also perform too much due diligence, apparently. “You can overdo it,” says Murphy. “You can talk yourself out of a lot of things by talking with the right or wrong people. It’s easy to wobble between calls. A lot of this stuff is a leap of faith, which is what makes this business so damn hard.”

“You can understand VCs wanting to avoid investing in the next Theranos,” agrees Abrams, who has raised millions of dollars from VCs across four companies and has personally invested in roughly 50 startups. “But getting too risk averse isn’t good either. Sometimes, companies where there are red flags in the beginning end up producing the largest wins.” Uber is a prime example, he notes.

Yet the biggest sin committed by investors is simply relying too heavily on their peers’ reputations as a form of due diligence. (It is not.)

Clinkle — a payments company whose $25 million “seed” round in 2013 was billed as the “largest in Silicon Valley history” —  is perhaps the highest-profile example of this type of misguided thinking. Its syndicate included Accel Partners, Andreessen Horowitz, Intel and Intuit, along with more than a dozen tech celebrities, including Peter Thiel and Marc Benioff. The company’s product never reached the market. Instead, by the spring of last year, Clinkle had largely imploded.

The WSJ has similarly suggested it was the endorsement of DFJ, which has backed Space X, Tesla Motors, and Planet Labs, and that wrote Theranos its first check, that attracted further investment to the company. Star power seemingly attracted star power to uBeam, too. Its backers include billionaire Mark Cuban, Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer, Peter Thiel’s Founders Fund and Andreessen Horowitz.

“I don’t think [founders] are necessarily trying to mislead anyone,” says Ackerman. But they “borrow credibility from others – their advisors, their directors — knowing if they borrow that stature, it will make it easier for them to fundraise. You especially see that behavior become pronounced when the money is flowing.”

“I’ve been surprised how some investors will oftentimes just go in behind a big brand, like, ‘Hey, if this is KP and Sequoia, and [the deal includes] this partner and this sector, we need to move quickly,’” says Murphy, who insists that smart VCs know better.

“If there was a blind spot you could have checked out [and didn’t], then shame on you,” he adds.

Three sides to every story

Of course, venture investing is based on taking risks. It means making bets on technologies in a world that’s changing faster than ever. Aside from the obvious challenges around fraud and founders who inflate their abilities, there’s always a danger that a company’s technology will check out on paper but not survive in the marketplace for one reason or another.

“Environments change. People change,” says Ryan Sarver, a former product director at Twitter who joined Redpoint Ventures two-and-a-half years ago as a partner. “After you invest, things sometimes change that you couldn’t have predicted.”

It happened to Ackerman, he says. “A bunch of years ago, we invested in a technology out of Stanford, and based on our review and the developers of the tech and what was going on in the marketplace, we viewed it as really disruptive.”

What Ackerman says he didn’t understand was “how much of the fundamental science was left to be proven. We were doing groundbreaking stuff, and we weren’t as close to the end of the process as we collectively thought we were. We started making assumptions about where the problems were going to be, and we realized there were a lot more problems to be resolved than we’d anticipated.”

In the end, says Ackerman, the product missed its window.

He regrets that, but he doesn’t beat himself up about it, either. It’s the nature of the beast.

“There was no real road map. We thought we were at Y but we were at X. I’m not sure there was another way to discover that.”

More TechCrunch

The families of victims of the shooting at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, Texas are suing Activision and Meta, as well as gun manufacturer Daniel Defense. The families bringing the…

Families of Uvalde shooting victims sue Activision and Meta

Like most Silicon Valley VCs, what Garry Tan sees is opportunities for new, huge, lucrative businesses.

Y Combinator’s Garry Tan supports some AI regulation but warns against AI monopolies

Everything in society can feel geared toward optimization – whether that’s standardized testing or artificial intelligence algorithms. We’re taught to know what outcome you want to achieve, and find the…

How Maven’s AI-run ‘serendipity network’ can make social media interesting again

Miriam Vogel, profiled as part of TechCrunch’s Women in AI series, is the CEO of the nonprofit responsible AI advocacy organization EqualAI.

Women in AI: Miriam Vogel stresses the need for responsible AI

Google has been taking heat for some of the inaccurate, funny, and downright weird answers that it’s been providing via AI Overviews in search. AI Overviews are the AI-generated search…

What are Google’s AI Overviews good for?

When it comes to the world of venture-backed startups, some issues are universal, and some are very dependent on where the startups and its backers are located. It’s something we…

The ups and downs of investing in Europe, with VCs Saul Klein and Raluca Ragab

Welcome back to TechCrunch’s Week in Review — TechCrunch’s newsletter recapping the week’s biggest news. Want it in your inbox every Saturday? Sign up here. OpenAI announced this week that…

Scarlett Johansson brought receipts to the OpenAI controversy

Accurate weather forecasts are critical to industries like agriculture, and they’re also important to help prevent and mitigate harm from inclement weather events or natural disasters. But getting forecasts right…

Deal Dive: Can blockchain make weather forecasts better? WeatherXM thinks so

pcTattletale’s website was briefly defaced and contained links containing files from the spyware maker’s servers, before going offline.

Spyware app pcTattletale was hacked and its website defaced

Featured Article

Synapse, backed by a16z, has collapsed, and 10 million consumers could be hurt

Synapse’s bankruptcy shows just how treacherous things are for the often-interdependent fintech world when one key player hits trouble. 

1 day ago
Synapse, backed by a16z, has collapsed, and 10 million consumers could be hurt

Sarah Myers West, profiled as part of TechCrunch’s Women in AI series, is managing director at the AI Now institute.

Women in AI: Sarah Myers West says we should ask, ‘Why build AI at all?’

Keeping up with an industry as fast-moving as AI is a tall order. So until an AI can do it for you, here’s a handy roundup of recent stories in the world…

This Week in AI: OpenAI and publishers are partners of convenience

Evan, a high school sophomore from Houston, was stuck on a calculus problem. He pulled up Answer AI on his iPhone, snapped a photo of the problem from his Advanced…

AI tutors are quietly changing how kids in the US study, and the leading apps are from China

Welcome to Startups Weekly — Haje‘s weekly recap of everything you can’t miss from the world of startups. Sign up here to get it in your inbox every Friday. Well,…

Startups Weekly: Drama at Techstars. Drama in AI. Drama everywhere.

Last year’s investor dreams of a strong 2024 IPO pipeline have faded, if not fully disappeared, as we approach the halfway point of the year. 2024 delivered four venture-backed tech…

From Plaid to Figma, here are the startups that are likely — or definitely — not having IPOs this year

Federal safety regulators have discovered nine more incidents that raise questions about the safety of Waymo’s self-driving vehicles operating in Phoenix and San Francisco.  The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration…

Feds add nine more incidents to Waymo robotaxi investigation

Terra One’s pitch deck has a few wins, but also a few misses. Here’s how to fix that.

Pitch Deck Teardown: Terra One’s $7.5M Seed deck

Chinasa T. Okolo researches AI policy and governance in the Global South.

Women in AI: Chinasa T. Okolo researches AI’s impact on the Global South

TechCrunch Disrupt takes place on October 28–30 in San Francisco. While the event is a few months away, the deadline to secure your early-bird tickets and save up to $800…

Disrupt 2024 early-bird tickets fly away next Friday

Another week, and another round of crazy cash injections and valuations emerged from the AI realm. DeepL, an AI language translation startup, raised $300 million on a $2 billion valuation;…

Big tech companies are plowing money into AI startups, which could help them dodge antitrust concerns

If raised, this new fund, the firm’s third, would be its largest to date.

Harlem Capital is raising a $150 million fund

About half a million patients have been notified so far, but the number of affected individuals is likely far higher.

US pharma giant Cencora says Americans’ health information stolen in data breach

Attention, tech enthusiasts and startup supporters! The final countdown is here: Today is the last day to cast your vote for the TechCrunch Disrupt 2024 Audience Choice program. Voting closes…

Last day to vote for TC Disrupt 2024 Audience Choice program

Featured Article

Signal’s Meredith Whittaker on the Telegram security clash and the ‘edge lords’ at OpenAI 

Among other things, Whittaker is concerned about the concentration of power in the five main social media platforms.

2 days ago
Signal’s Meredith Whittaker on the Telegram security clash and the ‘edge lords’ at OpenAI 

Lucid Motors is laying off about 400 employees, or roughly 6% of its workforce, as part of a restructuring ahead of the launch of its first electric SUV later this…

Lucid Motors slashes 400 jobs ahead of crucial SUV launch

Google is investing nearly $350 million in Flipkart, becoming the latest high-profile name to back the Walmart-owned Indian e-commerce startup. The Android-maker will also provide Flipkart with cloud offerings as…

Google invests $350 million in Indian e-commerce giant Flipkart

A Jio Financial unit plans to purchase customer premises equipment and telecom gear worth $4.32 billion from Reliance Retail.

Jio Financial unit to buy $4.32B of telecom gear from Reliance Retail

Foursquare, the location-focused outfit that in 2020 merged with Factual, another location-focused outfit, is joining the parade of companies to make cuts to one of its biggest cost centers –…

Foursquare just laid off 105 employees

“Running with scissors is a cardio exercise that can increase your heart rate and require concentration and focus,” says Google’s new AI search feature. “Some say it can also improve…

Using memes, social media users have become red teams for half-baked AI features

The European Space Agency selected two companies on Wednesday to advance designs of a cargo spacecraft that could establish the continent’s first sovereign access to space.  The two awardees, major…

ESA prepares for the post-ISS era, selects The Exploration Company, Thales Alenia to develop cargo spacecraft