Opera backs IAB’s ‘Lean’ effort to make ads less annoying — with caveats

Comment

Image Credits:

After adding a built-in ad-blocker to its desktop browser back in March, Opera stepped into and stepped up the debate about online ad-blocking.

The company has argued killing ads makes for a better consumer browsing experience, flagging up faster speeds and lower data consumption gleaned once ads are stripped away, and arguing generally that ads have become “one of the major annoyances of web browsing”.

It has also just now started the rollout of its ad-blocker to its suite of mobile browsers, beginning with Opera Mini for Android. So it’s stuck to its guns thus far, despite taking some flak from publishers and, inevitably, the ad industry, for its decision to default switch on ad-blocking for its users.

But as my TC colleague Frederic Lardinois has pointed out, there are a few odd notes here — not least that Opera itself owns an online advertising firm (Opera Mediaworks). It is also in the process of, albeit perhaps unwillingly, being acquired by a consortium of Chinese companies that includes several ad companies.

Whatever Opera’s multi-threaded motivations, it has now thrown the ad industry a bit of a bone — with the promise of juicier meat, should it show it can truly reform its ways when it comes to key consumer issues such as page load speeds, page bloat, privacy and general ad trickery/annoyance.

In a blog post yesterday, Opera’s SVP of global engineering, Krystian Kolondra, asserted the company does not hate ads but rather wants the industry to adapt to meet consumers’ expectations, pointing to how browsers helped curtail annoying pop-ups ads in the past as an example of how ad makers have adapted to browser-enforced changes before.

And bringing up the concept of ad whitelists by noting that Opera provides a tool where users can test how heavy a webpage’s ads are in order to “make an informed choice about whether or not they want to block ads or add a page to their own whitelist”.

Kolondra then says Opera considered building its own whitelist of ‘acceptable ads’ — to borrow the phrasing used by desktop ad-block company Adblock Plus (whose business model involves ad giants paying it to have their ads whitelisted, provided those ads also conform to its set of guidelines about contextual relevance, low intrusiveness and so on).

He writes:

We think browser-level or server-side native ad blocking is faster and better than extensions or other third-party tools. Opera currently only features a very small whitelist of websites, but we’re aware we need to provide a better solution for the future. The big question is: which ads are good, which are bad for the users, and who is responsible for making it better?

However at this point it looks like Opera is not going to seek to replicate a whitelist-style ad business model of its own. Rather Kolondra says it intends to work with an ad industry standardization effort to drive change — albeit, with an implicit threat that if this initiative doesn’t live up to consumer expectations, Opera may have to have a rethink.

“We first considered implementing our own solution, but after discussing with industry bodies like Internet Advertising Bureau (IAB), we think we can influence the ad industry to change by working together with them on their existing standardization efforts,” writes Kolondra, adding that Opera is “now talking with IAB to see how a browser can implement support for their LEAN initiative, once this is ready, if it truly manages to serve the end user needs for speed“.

(Emphasis his.)

The Lean initiative — which stands for ‘Light, Encrypted, Ad choice supported, Non-invasive ads’ — was launched by the IAB in October last year, in direct response to the rise in popularity of ad-blocking technologies. Although it is not aimed at overhauling ad standards entirely. But rather an attempt to create an alternative set of standards to, in the words of the IAB, “provide choice for marketers, content providers, and consumers”.

Whether the ad industry has the ability to reform its practices wholesale seems doubtful. But the prospect of a sub-set of so-called ‘Lean’ ads being whitelisted by browsers like Opera in future — thereby providing an incentive for more ad companies to adhere to these alternative standards — seems to be the thinking here.

It’s not entirely clear what Lean ads means in practice at this point, either, although the IAB specifically references two of the many necessary “areas of concentration”, as it puts it, as:

  • frequency capping on retargeting in adtech so that a user is “targeted appropriately before, but never AFTER they make a purchase” (i.e. fewer ads that stalk you around the Internet after you looked at buying a curtain that one time… );
  • and the volume of ads per page” — with the IAB talking opaquely about continuing “on the path to viewability”. So presumably that translates to: stopping larding so many ads into webpages that it makes seeing actual content hideously and horribly hard

So, for Opera, as a company with its own ad subsidiary and potentially also soon the subsidiary of a bunch of ad companies, a compromise strategy on ad-blocking that involves whitelisting a subset of better ads appears to be a little more coherent than an out-and-out anti-ad stance.

Albeit, as TC’s Frederic Lardinois has previously noted, the company has been going through a period of uncertainty in recent times — with CEO Lars Boilesen telling TechCrunch earlier this year that the in-train acquisition wasn’t really his decision and that the company would be just fine if the deal never closed. One suggestion therefore being that Opera’s ad-blocking push might in fact be an attempt to provoke its potential acquirers and perhaps sabotage the deal.

More TechCrunch

When Alex Ewing was a kid growing up in Purcell, Oklahoma, he knew how close he was to home based on which billboards he could see out the car window.…

OneScreen.ai brings startup ads to billboards and NYC’s subway

SpaceX’s massive Starship rocket could take to the skies for the fourth time on June 5, with the primary objective of evaluating the second stage’s reusable heat shield as the…

SpaceX sent Starship to orbit — the next launch will try to bring it back

Eric Lefkofsky knows the public listing rodeo well and is about to enter it for a fourth time. The serial entrepreneur, whose net worth is estimated at nearly $4 billion,…

Billionaire Groupon founder Eric Lefkofsky is back with another IPO: AI health tech Tempus

TechCrunch Disrupt showcases cutting-edge technology and innovation, and this year’s edition will not disappoint. Among thousands of insightful breakout session submissions for this year’s Audience Choice program, five breakout sessions…

You’ve spoken! Meet the Disrupt 2024 breakout session audience choice winners

Check Point is the latest security vendor to fix a vulnerability in its technology, which it sells to companies to protect their networks.

Zero-day flaw in Check Point VPNs is ‘extremely easy’ to exploit

Though Spotify never shared official numbers, it’s likely that Car Thing underperformed or was just not worth continued investment in today’s tighter economic market.

Spotify offers Car Thing refunds as it faces lawsuit over bricking the streaming device

The studies, by researchers at MIT, Ben-Gurion University, Cambridge and Northeastern, were independently conducted but complement each other well.

Misinformation works, and a handful of social ‘supersharers’ sent 80% of it in 2020

Welcome back to TechCrunch Mobility — your central hub for news and insights on the future of transportation. Sign up here for free — just click TechCrunch Mobility! Okay, okay…

Tesla shareholder sweepstakes and EV layoffs hit Lucid and Fisker

In a series of posts on X on Thursday, Paul Graham, the co-founder of startup accelerator Y Combinator, brushed off claims that OpenAI CEO Sam Altman was pressured to resign…

Paul Graham claims Sam Altman wasn’t fired from Y Combinator

In its three-year history, EthonAI has amassed some fairly high-profile customers including Siemens and chocolate-maker Lindt.

AI manufacturing startup funding is on a tear as Switzerland’s EthonAI raises $16.5M

Don’t miss out: TechCrunch Disrupt early-bird pricing ends in 48 hours! The countdown is on! With only 48 hours left, the early-bird pricing for TechCrunch Disrupt 2024 will end on…

Ticktock! 48 hours left to nab your early-bird tickets for Disrupt 2024

Biotech startup Valar Labs has built a tool that accurately predicts certain treatment outcomes, potentially saving precious time for patients.

Valar Labs debuts AI-powered cancer care prediction tool and secures $22M

Archer Aviation is partnering with ride-hailing and parking company Kakao Mobility to bring electric air taxi flights to South Korea starting in 2026, if the company can get its aircraft…

Archer, Kakao Mobility partner to bring electric air taxis to South Korea in 2026

Space startup Basalt Technologies started in a shed behind a Los Angeles dentist’s office, but things have escalated quickly: Soon it will try to “hack” a derelict satellite and install…

Basalt plans to ‘hack’ a defunct satellite to install its space-specific OS

As a teen model, Katrin Kaurov became financially independent at a young age. Aleksandra Medina, whom she met at NYU Abu Dhabi, also learned to manage money early on. The…

Former teen model co-created app Frich to help Gen Z be more realistic about finances

Can AI help you tell your story? That’s the idea behind a startup called Autobiographer, which leverages AI technology to engage users in meaningful conversations about the events in their…

Autobiographer’s app uses AI to help you tell your life story

AI-powered summaries of web pages are a feature that you will find in many AI-centric tools these days. The next step for some of these tools is to prepare detailed…

Perplexity AI’s new feature will turn your searches into shareable pages

ChatGPT, OpenAI’s text-generating AI chatbot, has taken the world by storm. What started as a tool to hyper-charge productivity through writing essays and code with short text prompts has evolved…

ChatGPT: Everything you need to know about the AI-powered chatbot

Battery recycling startups have emerged in Europe in a bid to tap into the next big opportunity in the EV market: battery waste.  Among them is Cylib, a German-based startup…

Cylib wants to own EV battery recycling in Europe

Amazon has received approval from the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to fly its delivery drones longer distances, the company announced on Thursday. Amazon says it can now expand its…

Amazon gets FAA approval to expand US drone deliveries

With Plannin, creators can tell their audience about their latest trip, which hotels they liked and post photos of their travels.

Former Priceline execs debut Plannin, a booking platform that uses travel influencers to help plan trips

Amazon is rolling out its AI voice search feature to Alexa, which lets it answer open-ended questions about content.

Amazon is rolling out AI voice search to Fire TV devices

Redpanda has already integrated Benthos into its own service and has made it the core technology of its new Redpanda Connect service.

Redpanda acquires Benthos to expand its end-to-end streaming data platform

It’s a lofty goal to take on legacy payments infrastructure, however, Forward’s model has an advantage by shifting the economics back to SaaS companies.

Fintech startup Forward grabs $16M to take on Stripe, lead future of integrated payments

Fertility remains a pressing concern around the world — birthrates are down in many countries, and infertility rates (that is, the inability to conceive) are up. Rhea, a Singapore- and…

Rhea reaps $10M more led by Thiel

Microsoft, Meta, Intel, AMD and others have formed a new group to design next-gen interconnects for AI accelerator hardware.

Tech giants form an industry group to help develop next-gen AI chip components

With JioFinance, the Indian tycoon Mukesh Ambani is making his boldest consumer-facing move yet into financial services.

Ambani’s Reliance fires opening salvo in fintech battle, launches JioFinance app

Salespeople live and die by commissions. It’s no surprise, then, that Salesforce paid a premium to buy a platform that simplifies managing commissions.

Filing shows Salesforce paid $419M to buy Spiff in February

YoLa Fresh works with over a thousand retailers across Morocco and records up to $1 million in gross merchandise volume.

YoLa Fresh, a GrubMarket for Morocco, digs up $7M to connect farmers with food sellers

Instagram is expanding the scope of its “Limits” tool specifically for teenagers that would let them restrict unwanted interactions with people.

Instagram now lets teens limit interactions to their ‘Close Friends’ group to combat harassment