Startups

The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative’s Chief Of Staff Reveals Plan For Big-Bet Philanthropy

Comment

Image Credits:

“They are willing to embrace risk and invest in things that may take 10, 20, 50 years to show really concrete results and that’s amazing,” says Caitlyn Fox, chief of staff of the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative.

After weeks of critics jumping to conclusions before seeing details or results, Fox spoke with me for nearly an hour about the strategy for Priscilla and Mark’s philanthropic foundation.

CZI will be structured similarly to Facebook’s acquisitions. The couple will entrust expert leaders to pursue pioneering solutions to huge problems without much micromanagement. The goal is to use the flexibility afforded by organizing the Chan-Zuckerberg fortune as an LLC rather than a non-profit to experiment in search of impact with agility.

In a sense, CZI looks as much like a startup as a charity. That nontraditional nature rightfully raises questions about process and results. Taking larger risks means there’s a chance a few of the efforts funded by Mark’s $45 billion in Facebook riches will fail or fall short.

But some of today and tomorrow’s most urgent challenges, diseases and injustices won’t be beaten by incrementally addressing their symptoms. The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative’s configuration gives it the freedom and funding to take big swings at the causes of humanity’s troubles.

Chan and Zuckerberg can’t do it all themselves. Priscilla is working as a doctor and overseeing The Primary School, the couple’s attempt at reimagining K-8 education. Mark is running one of the largest companies on the planet. They don’t have the time or ground-level understanding necessary to lead efforts to alleviate poverty, advance medicine, improve politics or reduce inequality. They know this.

“A big pillar of their philosophy in general is enabling leaders in each of these areas,” Fox tells me. She explains that Chan and Zuckerberg will still get deep in the areas of interest to determine who the most visionary leaders are. Once they’ve recruited experts they trust, the couple will enable them to direct the foundation’s resources.

It mirrors how Mark has organized Facebook’s acquisitions of companies like Instagram, Oculus and WhatsApp. He’s empowered Kevin Systrom, Brendan Iribe and Jan Koum to run their products quite autonomously. They’re the experts on photos, virtual reality and international messaging. Zuck believed they’d continue to be the best people to lead their companies, but now with a common purpose under the Facebook banner.

Other tech giants’ acquisitions have stalled or disintegrated under the heavy yoke of their parent companies. Yet the independence granted to Facebook’s buys have propelled each to new heights of impact. Now Zuckerberg is bringing that game plan to philanthropy.

“So instead of micromanaging each individual investment, it’s more about finding the people that they trust to then help them make those decisions,” Fox says.

12307963_554727371343572_5604052078312915070_o

Taking on a higher risk profile could make CZI a complement to more traditional approaches. Mark’s Facebook co-founder Dustin Moskovitz and his wife Cari’s foundation Good Ventures focuses on data-driven philanthropy. At first they foucsed on approaches that maximize the concrete benefit of each dollar like mosquito nets and direct cash transfers. But Good Ventures has evolved. Now it and CZI will both back risky long-term concepts for changing the world that old-school charities shy from. [Update: This passage has been edited to more accurately reflect Good Ventures’ focus.]

The organizations with tried-and-true models for impact need someone to blaze the trail. Fox told me CZI could potentially test and identify ways to help and funnel them toward more reserved sources of funding. That could include hard science attempts at curing diseases or generating energy, self-sustaining for-profit models that don’t require constant donations — moonshot philanthropy.

Fox will bring her experience in management consulting and defining strategy at The Rockefeller Foundation to her role as chief of staff at CZI. This won’t be the first time the Wharton Business School graduate applies the ideals of charity to for-profit models.

The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative's Chief Of Staff, Caitlyn Fox
Caitlyn Fox, Chan Zuckerberg Initiative chief of staff

There are plenty of open questions for her to answer at CZI. The organization is still hammering out how to measure success for its long-term plays. Meanwhile, it’s determining how to best discover what to support.

Currently it’s not accepting unsolicited proposals. CZI hasn’t taken a stance on whether funding the arts or doing direct cash transfers to those in need will be part of its efforts. And Fox admitted that the public’s concerns about how the LLC structure works are valid, but urged people to reserve judgment until CZI had results to show.

One way it seeks to maximize those results is keeping CZI as lean as possible. Fox says this has two main advantages. First, keeping a lower headcount ensures as much money as possible goes to the causes themselves. And second, it keeps Chan, Zuckerberg and the experts they trust close to the situation, creating short feedback loops so they can learn and course-correct as quickly as possible.

Transparency will be of particular interest to both CZI and its critics. Fox says the foundation endeavors to be incredibly transparent. However, she noted that in some cases, especially when CZI co-invests with other groups, the grantee doesn’t want added attention. Or if it invests in the for-profit sector, it may not immediately disclose its involvement. That secrecy could ruffle feathers since some might argue open collaboration among problem solvers would accelerate results. Yet by backing private companies, CZI could earn outsized returns that it plans to reinvest in doing good.

Much of the backlash against CZI has focused on Zuckerberg’s history as one of the most successful technologists of all time. Yet critics have largely ignored the fact that the name of the foundation starts with Chan, who Dr. Sam Hawgood, the chancellor of the University Of California, San Francisco, lauded for her “commitment to the most under-served in our communities” during medical school. Fox tells me that while Zuckerberg brings his visionary insight and optimism, Chan grounds their work with perspective from her time as a teacher and doctor.

By starting early, the duo will have plenty of time to grow as benefactors. While other major donors didn’t earn or pledge their billions until later in life, Chan and Zuckerberg’s youth is an opportunity.

“They’re very patient philanthropists,” Fox says. “They don’t need clear results in a year, in two years. That means CZI’s funding will require even more responsible allocation in the near-term to minimize waste. But if Chan and Zuckerberg can find the right approaches and the right people to execute them, they have a chance to address our world’s most vexing dilemmas. Not just those that affect us today or their newborn daughter Max, but that loom over generations to come.

More TechCrunch

Call Arc can help answer immediate and small questions, according to the company. 

Arc Search’s new Call Arc feature lets you ask questions by ‘making a phone call’

After multiple delays, Apple and the Paris area transportation authority rolled out support for Paris transit passes in Apple Wallet. It means that people can now use their iPhone or…

Paris transit passes now available in iPhone’s Wallet app

Redwood Materials, the battery recycling startup founded by former Tesla co-founder JB Straubel, will be recycling production scrap for batteries going into General Motors electric vehicles.  The company announced Thursday…

Redwood Materials is partnering with Ultium Cells to recycle GM’s EV battery scrap

A new startup called Auggie is aiming to give parents a single platform where they can shop for products and connect with each other. The company’s new app, which launched…

Auggie’s new app helps parents find community and shop

Andrej Safundzic, Alan Flores Lopez and Leo Mehr met in a class at Stanford focusing on ethics, public policy and technological change. Safundzic — speaking to TechCrunch — says that…

Lumos helps companies manage their employees’ identities — and access

Remark trains AI models on human product experts to create personas that can answer questions with the same style of their human counterparts.

Remark puts thousands of human product experts into AI form

ZeroPoint claims to have solved compression problems with hyper-fast, low-level memory compression that requires no real changes to the rest of the computing system.

ZeroPoint’s nanosecond-scale memory compression could tame power-hungry AI infrastructure

In 2021, Roi Ravhon, Asaf Liveanu and Yizhar Gilboa came together to found Finout, an enterprise-focused toolset to help manage and optimize cloud costs. (We covered the company’s launch out…

Finout lands cash to grow its cloud spend management platform

On the heels of raising $102 million earlier this year, Bugcrowd is making good on its promise to use some of that funding to make acquisitions to strengthen its security…

Bugcrowd, the crowdsourced white-hat hacker platform, acquires Informer to ramp up its security chops

Google is preparing to build what will be the first subsea fibre optic cable connecting the continents of Africa and Australia. The news comes as the major cloud hyperscalers battle…

Google to build first subsea fibre optic cable connecting Africa with Australia

The Kia EV3 — the new all-electric compact SUV revealed Thursday — illustrates a growing appetite among global automakers to bring generative AI into their vehicles.  The automaker said the…

The new Kia EV3 will have an AI assistant with ChatGPT DNA

Bing, Microsoft’s search engine, isn’t working properly right now. At first, we noticed it wasn’t possible to perform a web search at all. Now it seems search results are loading…

Bing’s API is down, taking Microsoft Copilot, DuckDuckGo and ChatGPT’s web search feature down too

If you thought autonomous driving was just for cars, think again. The so-called ‘autonomous navigation’ market — where ships steer themselves guided by AI, resulting in fuel and time savings…

Autonomous shipping startup Orca AI tops up with $23M led by OCV Partners and MizMaa Ventures

The best known mycoprotein is probably Quorn, a meat substitute that’s fast approaching its 40th birthday. But Finnish biotech startup Enifer is cooking up something even older: Its proprietary single-cell…

Meet the Finnish biotech startup bringing a long lost mycoprotein to your plate

Silo, a Bay Area food supply chain startup, has hit a rough patch. TechCrunch has learned that the company on Tuesday laid off roughly 30% of its staff, or north…

Food supply chain software maker Silo lays off ~30% of staff amid M&A discussions

Featured Article

Meta’s new AI council is composed entirely of white men

Meanwhile, women and people of color are disproportionately impacted by irresponsible AI.

17 hours ago
Meta’s new AI council is composed entirely of white men

If you’ve ever wanted to apply to Y Combinator, here’s some inside scoop on how the iconic accelerator goes about choosing companies.

Garry Tan has revealed his ‘secret sauce’ for getting into Y Combinator

Indian ride-hailing startup BluSmart has started operating in Dubai, TechCrunch has exclusively learned and confirmed with its executive. The move to Dubai, which has been rumored for months, could help…

India’s BluSmart is testing its ride-hailing service in Dubai

Under the envisioned framework, both candidate and issue ads would be required to include an on-air and filed disclosure that AI-generated content was used.

FCC proposes all AI-generated content in political ads must be disclosed

Want to make a founder’s day, week, month, and possibly career? Refer them to Startup Battlefield 200 at Disrupt 2024! Applications close June 10 at 11:59 p.m. PT. TechCrunch’s Startup…

Refer a founder to Startup Battlefield 200 at Disrupt 2024

Social networking startup and X competitor Bluesky is officially launching DMs (direct messages), the company announced on Wednesday. Later, Bluesky plans to “fully support end-to-end encrypted messaging down the line,”…

Bluesky now has DMs

The perception in Silicon Valley is that every investor would love to be in business with Peter Thiel. But the venture capital fundraising environment has become so difficult that even…

Peter Thiel-founded Valar Ventures raised a $300 million fund, half the size of its last one

Featured Article

Spyware found on US hotel check-in computers

Several hotel check-in computers are running a remote access app, which is leaking screenshots of guest information to the internet.

20 hours ago
Spyware found on US hotel check-in computers

Gavet has had a rocky tenure at Techstars and her leadership was the subject of much controversy.

Techstars CEO Maëlle Gavet is out

The struggle isn’t universal, however.

Connected fitness is adrift post-pandemic

Featured Article

A comprehensive list of 2024 tech layoffs

The tech layoff wave is still going strong in 2024. Following significant workforce reductions in 2022 and 2023, this year has already seen 60,000 job cuts across 254 companies, according to independent layoffs tracker Layoffs.fyi. Companies like Tesla, Amazon, Google, TikTok, Snap and Microsoft have conducted sizable layoffs in the first months of 2024. Smaller-sized…

22 hours ago
A comprehensive list of 2024 tech layoffs

HoundDog actually looks at the code a developer is writing, using both traditional pattern matching and large language models to find potential issues.

HoundDog.ai helps developers prevent personal information from leaking

The changes are designed to enhance the consumer experience of using Google Pay and make it a more competitive option against other payment methods.

Google Pay will now display card perks, BNPL options and more

Few figures in the tech industry have earned the storied reputation of Vinod Khosla, founder and partner at Khosla Ventures. For over 40 years, he has been at the center…

Vinod Khosla is coming to Disrupt to discuss how AI might change the future